, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

It was therefore decided to focus the own-initiative inquiry on the question of whether Community institutions and bodies other than the Council and Commission had established publicly available rules on access to the documents they hold.

In the present state of Community law, the inquiry was confined to whether rules exist and are publicly available. It did not ask whether the rules themselves are the right ones to ensure the degree of transparency that European citizens increasingly expect of the Union. In fact, the Commission and Council rules are quite limited compared to the rules governing some national administrations. In particular, they do not require registers of documents to be published. Nor do they give any right of access to documents held by one body, but originating in another.

The institutions and bodies covered by the inquiry

The inquiry was addressed to fifteen Community institutions and bodies, consisting of:

–

the Community institutions in the sense of Article 4 of the Treaty, other than the Council and Commission;

–

four bodies established by the Treaty, and

–

eight of the ten 'decentralized Community agencies`. (The remaining two decentralized agencies - the Community Plant Variety Office and the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work - were excluded from the inquiry because they were not yet operational).

The inquiry

The Ombudsman asked the institutions and bodies to inform him about their situation as regards public access to documents and in particular whether they had issued general rules which are easily available to the public or internal guidelines to staff on public access and confidentiality.

The replies contained information about requirements of confidentiality and information policies, as well as about rules and guidelines on public access to documents.

Confidentiality requirements

Some replies referred to requirements of Community law that certain types of document should be confidential. This information is important, because rules about access to documents that are adopted as a matter of internal organisation must be consistent with existing legal obligations of confidentiality. However, it did not appear that any of the institutions or bodies gave public access to all documents that were not specifically covered by legal obligations of confidentiality.

Information policies