The Commission claimed that it was impossible in practice to write a detailed individual analysis for each rejected proposal. The letter informing unsuccessful applicants therefore uses a standard format summarily stating the reasons in general and expressly inviting unsuccessful applicants to contact CEV/EEP for further explanations. According to the Commission, CEV/EEP does not transmit the evaluators' reports to the applicants, but habitually makes these accessible to the applicants concerned and discusses the findings with them. The Commission claimed that Mr L. had not availed himself of the opportunity to receive from CEV/EEP further details about the rejection of his project.
Following analysis of the Commission's comments and the complainant's observations, the Ombudsman made further inquiries of the Commission. In response, the Commission stated that the qualitative evaluation provided by the group of experts applies only to stage 1 of the selection process. The evaluation divides the proposals into two main categories: those with a score higher than 50 % and those with a score below 50 %. This percentage is the outcome of the weighting breakdown published in the documentation folder. According to the Commission, however, when the unsuccessful applicant meets with representatives of CEV/EEP to discuss the shortcomings of the project, the comments made during the Advisory Group meeting, as well as any additional considerations by the Commission are shared, in addition to relevant points from the evaluators' reports. The objective of these meetings is to assist the applicant in finding the strengths and weaknesses of the project, so that a future application may be more successful: the further explanations thus refer to the whole selection process.
The decision
1) The giving of reasons to unsuccessful applicants
1.1 In its replies to the Ombudsman, the Commission did not argue that it has no obligation to give reasons to unsuccessful applicants under the LIEN Phare-Tacis programme. On the contrary, the Commission emphasised that it seeks to
ensure the transparency of the selection procedure; and
assist applicants in finding the strengths and weaknesses of an unsuccessful project so that a future application may be more successful.
1.2 The questions at issue therefore concerned whether the reasons given were adequate to achieve these purposes. These questions had to be addressed in the context of the decision-making process to which they relate.