, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

In its comments on the complaint the Commission said that for the period 1989-1994 the information requested by the complainant was not directly available at the Commission and that meeting his request would be an expensive operation, involving searches by the Member States. As regards the earlier period, the Commission said it did have details which could serve as a basis for a search which might provide the information requested; it was prepared to carry out the search if the complainant confirmed his interest in that period.

The decision

The Ombudsman considered that the reasons given by the Commission regarding the period 1989-1994 were justified and noted the demonstration of its good will as regards the earlier period. On this basis he decided further inquiries were unnecessary and closed the case.

ACCESS TO A COMMISSION DOCUMENT

Decision on complaint 180/13.10.95/JPB/PD/B-dk against the European Commission

The complaint

Mr B., a Danish national, lodged a complaint about a Commission refusal to allow him access to documents. It appeared that in May 1995 he had asked to see a report on the promotion of growth which the Commission had drawn up. In September 1995, he was informed that the Commission refused his request on the grounds that it did not want to make the report public shortly before a conference on the subject it had scheduled for November 1995. On 11 September 1995, the complainant asked the Commission to reverse on its decision. As he did not receive any reply from the Commission, he lodged a complaint alleging that the Commission's attitude conflicted with the rules on access to documents laid down in its decision of 8 February 1994 on public access to Commission documents. This decision lays down the grounds for refusing access and a procedure for processing applications for access. The complainant alleged that the non-compliance with the deadline for processing such requests, provided for in the decision, should automatically entail the disclosure of the document.

The inquiry

In its first comments on the complaint, the Commission stated that it considered the complaint to be unfounded since it had, in the meantime, sent the report to the complainant. However, the complainant maintained his complaint.

  • celex=31971D0016