, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

After careful consideration of the information supplied by the Commission and the complainant, the Ombudsman decided that it was necessary to examine the documents held by the Commission relating to the complaint in order to satisfy himself that the decision to close the file had been made in conformity with general principles of good administrative behaviour. The examination was carried out on 5 November 1996.

The decision

1) The Commission's interpretation of the Directive

1.1 Article 3 of Directive 85/337/EEC provides that an environmental impact assessment will identify, describe and assess the effects of a project on various listed factors, including human beings and the air.

1.2 Article 5 requires Member States to adopt the necessary measures to ensure that the developer supplies in an appropriate form the information specified in Annex III. Annex III requires, amongst other things, estimates of air pollution and noise.

1.3 The obligation imposed on Member States by Article 5 of the Directive is qualified. Information only has to be provided inasmuch as a Member State considers:

a)

that it is relevant to:

a given stage of the consent procedure and

the specific characteristics of a particular project and of the environmental features likely to be affected; and

b)

that the developer may reasonably be required to compile the information having regard, inter alia, to current knowledge and methods of assessment.

1.4 Article 5 therefore requires an exercise of judgement by the Member State as to what information is to be provided and, in that sense, leaves the extent of the information required to be supplied to the discretion of the Member State.

1.5 The requirements of Article 3 of the Directive are expressed to be 'in accordance with the Articles 4 to 11.` Given that Annex III (referred to by Article 5) is more detailed than Article 3, it does not appear that the latter was intended to impose obligations on Member States independent of those under Article 5. It must be recalled, however, that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.

1.6 The Ombudsman's inquiries have not, therefore, revealed any instance of maladministration by the Commission in its interpretation of the information requirements of the Directive.

2) The Commission's analysis of its own role

  • celex=31985L0337