, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

In its reply, the Commission explained that, as laid down in Article 8 of the 'Rules for the reimbursement of travel and subsistence expenses for persons outside the Community invited to attend a competition, interview or medical examination` (hereinafter referred to as 'the Rules`), subsistence expenses were reimbursed by means of a daily allowance meant as a flat-rate contribution towards (and not as full reimbursement of) the candidate's expenses.

As to the train ticket from the airport to Brussels, the Rules make no provision for reimbursement; in practice, however, this fare was reimbursed at the candidate's request.

The special hotel rate arranged for the complainant in July 1995 was not a standard procedure and was only granted because of the shortness of the interval between the written and oral tests.

The comments of the Commission were sent to the complainant for his observations.

He informed the Ombudsman that he was not aware of the Rules and that he had not been informed that the special arrangement of July 1995 was an exceptional measure.

The decision

When the Commission invited Mr F. to Brussels for the medical examination and for interviews in September 1995, it stated in its letter that

'where appropriate, your travel expenses will be reimbursed according to the conditions set out on the attached form`.

The attached form contained the above-mentioned Rules. It appeared therefore that the Rules had been communicated to the complainant in September 1995. These Rules set out all the relevant conditions under which candidates are reimbursed. Mr F. was reimbursed pursuant to Article 8 (3) of the Rules, which provides for a flat-rate allowance of ECU 50 per day.

The candidate's expenses covered by this flat-rate allowance were accommodation, meals, and local transport, including the Brussels metro.

As to the train expenses from the airport to Brussels, the Commission confirmed to the Ombudsman that they had not been reimbursed due to an inadvertent error and that their reimbursement was currently under way.

In view of these findings, the European Ombudsman decided that no further inquiries were justified and closed the case.

ACCESS TO INFORMATION ON THE OUTCOME OF A COMPETITION

Decision on complaint 485/13.03.96/LV/B/KT-fr against the European Commission