, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

2) Summary reasons with further information available on request

2.1 It appeared that the Commission explained the rejection of proposals submitted under the LIEN Phare-Tacis programme by giving summary reasons in a standard form information sheet and made further information available on request.

2.2 It appeared from the Commission's replies that, for budgetary reasons, only 10 % of the projects submitted were financed and that projects with a high evaluation might not be financed. The process of selecting projects therefore appeared to have characteristics of a tendering procedure for a contract.

2.3 In this context, it is appropriate to refer by analogy to the provisions of the public services directive concerning the giving of reasons to unsuccessful tenderers. Article 12 of the directive (2) does not require reasons to be given automatically, but the contracting authority must inform any eliminated candidate or tenderer who so requests of the reasons for rejection of his application or tender.

2.4 The procedure adopted for the LIEN Phare-Tacis programme of giving summary reasons on a standard form information sheet, followed by more detailed information on request did not therefore appear inappropriate.

3) The transparency of the selection procedure

3.1 According to the Commission's replies, the further information made available on request covered all three stages of the selection procedure.

3.2 The published documentation folder about the LIEN programme contained a section headed 'who takes the decision to subvention the projects and who evaluates them?` This section of the documentation folder said that 'a group of experts receives, examines and evaluates applications and makes recommendations to the Commission which makes the final selection of projects.` This appears to be a fair, although abbreviated, description of the process.

3.3 The immediately following section of the documentation folder was headed 'what criteria are used for the evaluation of applications?` and explains the percentage weightings. According to the Commission's replies these were applied only at the first stage of the selection procedure.

  • celex=31952D0027