The European Ombudsman stated that, as the first letter of the complainant effectively arrived at the Parliament it should have been answered. Principles of good administration require that wrongly addressed mail should be transferred to the relevant service within the Parliament.
As to the demand to review the exam papers, there is no formal provision which confers a right on the applicant to have his exam papers reviewed a second time. The selection board is independent in its work and thus there is no possibility to address an appeal body for review of the marks given. However, the European Ombudsman was informed that some selection boards review the test results of an applicant if he so requests without undue delay. Parliament has not contested that the complainant's papers would have been reviewed by the selection board if the request had been submitted in time.
The European Ombudsman therefore criticised the fact that, because the complainant's first request for the review could not be located within the Parliament, the complainant's marks were not reviewed.
However, as the selection board had finished its work and as there was therefore no possibility to achieve a friendly solution in this matter, the European Ombudsman decided to close the case.
3.4.2 THE COUNCIL
EXCLUSION FROM A COMPETITION
Decision on complaint 129/19.9.95/TK/B against the Council of the European Union
The complaint
Mrs K., a Finnish national, complained about her exclusion from a competition for recruitment of translators by the Council. The competition was announced in February 1995. The notice of competition required candidates to:
have completed University level studies, recognised by a diploma or certificate confirming a completed course of study at a University [. . .] Candidates must prove, by means of documentary evidence, that they meet this condition of entry to the competition (copy of diplomas or certificates, . . .)