, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

3.4 Considered as a whole, the documentation folder contained useful information to assist applicants to formulate proposals and to enable them and others to understand how the Commission is putting the relevant Community policies into effect. However, the information given would have been more complete and potential confusion avoided if it had been made clear that the criteria and percentage weightings applied to the evaluation by experts and that the Commission's decision could include additional factors. The transparency of the procedure would also have been improved if the Commission had specified the additional factors it would take into account.

Conclusion

The Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint did not reveal any instance of maladministration by the Commission. The transparency of the selection procedure could be improved by making clear that the Commission's decision may include factors other than the criteria and percentage weightings. It would be further improved if the Commission were to specify what those factors are. The Ombudsman closed the case.

ACCESS TO INFORMATION HELD BY THE COMMISSION

Decision on complaints 69/16.08.95/WDR/PD/D-de and 70/16.08.95/SF/PD-D-de against the European Commission

The complaints

Mr M. and Mr W., German nationals, lodged complaints about a Commission official. They put forward that the official, whom they had approached in order to get a statement on a topic on which they were making a TV-report, had refused to give information and had not answered subsequent faxes.

As the two complaints concerned the same facts and they were lodged together, the Ombudsman decided to treat them jointly.

The inquiry

In its comments on the complaints, the Commission stated that the official concerned had not been in a position to give an interview to journalists, as Commission policy 'is to channel all contacts with journalists through the Spokesman's Service. It is, thus, the responsibility of this service to give interviews to journalists or, if appropriate, to decide that a competent official from another service should give such an interview. It would appear in this case that there may have been a misunderstanding in this respect and the Commission will take the necessary steps to avoid such misunderstandings in the future.` The Commission further stated that the public may have access to Commission documents in accordance with the Commission Decision of 8 February 1994 on public access to Commission documents.

  • celex=31969D0016