The complainants claim that the lists were in an area totally open to the public, with no physical barrier, and there was no notice banning the public from consulting the lists. They also maintained that the public had no idea within 'how many metres, decimetres or centimetres` they could approach the lists without infringing such a ban on public access to the lists.
The inquiry
The European Parliament's comments concerning the complaint were forwarded to the complainants, who then gave their observations.
The Ombudsman asked Parliament for further information. In the light of these elements, two officials from the Ombudsman's Office met with a representative of the European Parliament. Following this meeting the Ombudsman put forward a proposal to Parliament.
The comments by Parliament can be summarized as follows: the records of attendance are internal documents used among other things by Parliament's administration to determine the various allowances to which Members are entitled. The public has never had access to these lists but has always had access to the definitive lists which appear in the minutes of a sitting and are available the next day. The public has also always had access to the names of Members who have taken part in a roll-call vote, very often about half an hour after the vote. Finally, Parliament pointed out that the records of attendance concerned were formerly located within the Chamber. The only reason the lists are now outside the Chamber is that following the latest accessions of Member States to the Union there is no room for them inside the Chamber. Given these considerations, Parliament maintained the ban on access to the lists.
The decision
The Ombudsman first pointed out that, in the absence of general rules adopted by the Community legislator on public access to documents of the Community institutions, it was a matter for each Community institution to lay down rules in this connection by virtue of its power of internal organization.
Secondly, the Ombudsman noted that the information provided by the lists as regards the presence of a Member in the Chamber at any given moment was very limited, since Members are free to enter and leave the Chamber as they wish without having to sign the lists again.
On these grounds the Ombudsman found that, by virtue of its power of internal organization Parliament may refuse to allow public access to these lists, and that the lists were intended above all for administrative purposes.