, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

As regards the principles on which it should act, the Commission set out the criteria that it considers appropriate to use, in the context of Article 169, in cases concerning a Member State's exercise of discretion based on a complex appraisal such as environmental assessment under Directive 85/337/EEC. The Commission stated that it would 'limit its review to three main categories:

–

failure of procedural rules

–

facts on which the decision was taken were inaccurately stated,

–

manifest error of appraisal or misuse of powers.`

As regards the way in which it had dealt with the complaint, the Commission stated that it had written to the UK authorities, notifying them that a complaint had been received concerning the M40 project and asking for a copy of the environmental statement and the non-technical summary produced in relation to the project together with the assessment made of that information. The UK supplied a copy of the environmental statement for the project, the non-technical summary, and the seven-page reasoned decision granting development consent for the project.

The Commission further stated that it had considered the information supplied to it by the complainants and by the UK authorities and had formed the view that this information:

'a) disclosed no failure on the part of the United Kingdom to follow the procedural rules of Directive 85/337/EEC,

b)

disclosed no evidence that the facts on which the decision of the United Kingdom to grant development consent for the M40 project was taken were inaccurately stated,

c)

disclosed no evidence that the United Kingdom had committed a manifest error of appraisal or had misused its powers.

The Commission therefore considered that the information before it contained no grounds on which to conclude that the United Kingdom exercised its discretion under Directive 85/337/EEC in a manner contrary to the requirements of that Directive. There was therefore no basis on which the Commission could have correctly decided to bring a formal action against the United Kingdom under Article 169 of the Treaty.`

The examination of the file