4.2 The letter from DG XVI of 4 October 1994 indicated that, in principle, there would be one project per member state, but subject to the quality of the projects. There does not appear therefore to have been any specific commitment by the Commission as a matter of policy to one project per Member State. According to the Commission, of the seven projects selected for further examination only four were finally accepted.
4.3 In these circumstances, the fact that the outcome of the selection process did not represent one project per Member State does not appear to provide any grounds for criticism of the process. Nor do there appear to be any grounds for suspecting that there was discrimination against Italy in the selection process.
4.4 As regards the complainants' claim that all the projects should have been rejected, the fact that further examination of projects was undertaken does not appear to provide any grounds for considering that the projects concerned had not been properly submitted. It is normal that detailed examination should take place before public money is spent.
Conclusion
The Ombudsman's examination of this complaint revealed maladministration by the European Commission in the form of procedural errors as detailed in points 2.2 and 3.3 above. There appeared to be no evidence, however, to support the complainants' allegations of bad faith or discrimination.
Since the application procedure for pilot projects for 1994 was closed, it was not possible to pursue a friendly settlement of the matter. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
Further remarks by the Ombudsman
In its comments to the Ombudsman made on 15 May 1996, the Commission twice stated that the project of the foundation arrived at the Commission at the end of January 1995. In its later reply to the Ombudsman's specific question the Commission acknowledges that the project arrived at DG XV1 on 20 December 1994.
In view of point 2.3 of the above decision, this disparity has no practical significance. However, the Ombudsman is seriously concerned that part of the information supplied to him by the Commission during his inquiries into this complaint was wrong.
One of the most basic requirements of good administrative behaviour is to provide correct information, especially to the bodies responsible for scrutiny of their activities. The Ombudsman therefore requested the Commission to emphasise to its officials the importance of supplying accurate information to the Ombudsman.