, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The Ombudsman therefore took the view that it was unnecessary to make further inquiries. Accordingly, he decided to close the case. However, the Ombudsman considered that the Council should ensure that his criticisms of the Selection Board in his decision were brought to the attention of Selection Boards.

3.4.3 THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION

EUROPEAN COMMISSION'S HANDLING OF A COMPLAINT ABOUT LACK OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT: NEWBURY BYPASS

Decision on complaints

206/27.10.95/HS/UK, 211/03.11.95/JC/UK, 226/13.11.95/J./UK, 229/14.11.95/PAD/UK, 303/03.01.96/COW/UK, 327/08.01.96/RW/UK, 335/08.01.96/AK/UK, 358/15.01.96/EC/UK, 359/16.01.96/J./UK, 360/09.01.96/SJ/UK, 361/09.01.96/JB/UK, 362/15.01.96/JB/UK, 363/15.01.96/MN/UK, 364/03.11.95/J./UK, 377/31.1.96/ME/UK, 378/25.1.96/JB/UK, 382/24.1.96/CW/UK, 383/24.1.96/J./UK, 403./01.02.96/TA/UK, 71/4.3.96/PC/UK, 487/14.3.96/BARF/UK, 488/14.3.96/PB/UK, 514/25.3.96/DB/UK, 515/25.3.96/PJW/UK, 526/27.3.96/DAW/UK, 562/18.4.96/DD/UK, 607/24.5.96/BB/UK against the European Commission

The complainants alleged maladministration by the European Commission in deciding not to open infringement proceedings against the United Kingdom under Article 169 of the EC Treaty. They took the view that the UK government had breached Community law by failing to carry out an environmental impact assessment of the Newbury Bypass road in Berkshire, England.

In order to deal with them as effectively and promptly as possible, the complaints were treated jointly.

The background to the complaints

Council Directive 85/337/EEC (3) requires that, in certain cases, development consent for public or private projects should be given only after an environmental impact assessment. The latest date for transposition of the Directive into national law was 3 July 1988.

The Directive contains no transitional provisions. That is to say, it does not expressly state whether it applies in cases where the procedures leading to development consent began before the Directive came into force, but the consent itself was given after it came into force (so-called 'pipeline` cases).

In 1994, complaints were made to the European Commission alleging that the UK authorities had failed to observe the requirements of the Directive in relation to the Newbury Bypass. The Commission registered the complaints and opened a file in relation to the matter.