Mr JOSÉ MARÍA GIL-ROBLES GIL-DELGADO
President
European Parliament
97-113, rue Belliard
B - 1047 Brussels
Mr President,
In accordance with Article 138e (1) of the Treaty establishing the European Community and Article 3 (8) of the Decision of the European Parliament on the Regulations and General Conditions Governing the Performance of the Ombudsman's Duties, I hereby present my report for the year 1996.
JACOB SÖDERMAN
Ombudsman of the European Union
CONTENT
Page
FOREWORD BY THE EUROPEAN OMBUDSMAN . 4
COMPLAINTS TO THE OMBUDSMAN . 6
2.1. The legal basis of the Ombudsman's work . 6
2.2. How complaints are dealt with . 6
2.2.1. The mandate of the European Ombudsman . 7
2.2.2. Admissibility of complaints . 7
2.2.3. Grounds for inquiries . 8
2.3. Analysis of the complaints . 8
2.4. Advice to contact other agencies . 8
2.5. Decisions following an inquiry by the Ombudsman . 8
DECISIONS FOLLOWING AN INQUIRY . 10
3.1. Cases where no maladministration was found . 10
3.1.1. The European Parliament . 10
Termination of a contract . 10
3.1.2. The European Commission . 10
Nuclear tests in French Polynesia . 10
Method of assessment of LIEN Phare-Tacis applications . 11
Access to information held by the Commission . 13
Rights of persons on reserve list . 13
Access to information on Commission programmes . 14
Access to a Commission document . 14
Confidentiality of information about nuclear materials . 15
Measures taken after abolition of customs operations at borders . 16
Overcrowding at the Brussels II European School . 17
Recruitment from a reserve list after a competition . 18
Nationality as a condition for a grant . 18
3.2. Cases dropped by the complainant . 19
3.2.1. The European Commission and the European Parliament . 19
Incorrect information from the Commission and Parliament . 19
3.3. Cases settled by the institution . 20
3.3.1. The European Parliament . 20
Access to records of attendance of MEPs . 20
3.3.2. The Council . 20
Access to documents held by the Council . 20
3.3.3. The European Commission . 22
Financial compensation for preparatory work . 22
Delay in answering requests for information . 22
Failure to pay a promised subsidy . 23
Award of a blue flag, mark of cleanliness, to a beach . 23
Page
Late settlement of an invoice . 24
The directive on non-life insurance . 24
Reimbursement of travel and subsistence expenses . 25
Access to information on the outcome of a competition . 25
Delayed reply from the Commission . 26