, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

By letter dated 10 September 1992, the Commission informed the complainants that it had concluded that there was no infringement of Directive 85/337/EEC and that this conclusion had been reached after enquiries had been made of the United Kingdom authorities and after examination of the information provided by them. The letter also stated that the Commission was unable to let the complainants see a copy of the United Kingdom's response to its enquiries as such enquiries are made, and the replies are given, on a confidential basis.

The complaint to the UK Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration

Mr A. and Mr H. asked the UK authorities for access to the information put forward to the Commission. They were dissatisfied with the response they received and complained to the UK Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration.

In June 1995, the Parliamentary Commissioner, whilst critical of certain aspects of the way in which the request for access to information had been dealt with by the UK authorities, concluded that the complainants were mistaken in thinking that the information given to them by the UK authorities represented a less than full and frank picture of the exchanges between the Commission and the UK government.

The complaint

Following the report from the Parliamentary Commissioner, Mr A. and Mr H. complained to the European Ombudsman that:

1) they had submitted substantial evidence to the European Commission which proved beyond doubt that Directive 85/337/EEC had not been followed and correctly applied by the United Kingdom authorities;

2) the Commission had failed to make a full diligent and searching inquiry into the circumstances surrounding their complaint that the UK authorities' environmental assessment of the M40 widening project had been faulty but had accepted at face value and without demur the United Kingdom government's submission made in response to the complaint.

The inquiry

The Commission's initial response

In March 1996, the Commission sent the Ombudsman the following comments:

'The subject matter of the complaint involves a decision of the Commission with regard to proceedings under Article 169. The Court of Justice has consistently held that:

  • celex=31985L0337