, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

However, if Parliament did not wish the public to consult these lists, the Ombudsman thought it inappropriate to place them in an area open to the public where it was virtually impossible to ensure such a ban was observed. For that reason the Ombudsman finally suggested that as long as the lists were outside the Chamber, public access should not be prevented and that, by means of a note drawn up for the purpose, the parliamentary ushers might provide information about the official lists and the roll-call votes to people who were particularly interested.

In response to this suggestion, Parliament stated that the Secretary-General had been asked to put the lists back inside the Chamber and, if that was impossible, a written note about means of obtaining information about the presence of Members would be offered to persons interested.

Given Parliament's above-mentioned power of internal organization and the measures taken, the Ombudsman decided to close the case.

3.3.2 THE COUNCIL

ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS HELD BY THE COUNCIL

Decision on complaint 45/26.7.95/JPB/PD/B-dk against the Council of the European Union

The complaint

Mr B., a Danish national, lodged a complaint against the Council. He requested that all information necessary to understand existing legislation should be made public and that, as a Member of the European Parliament, he needed to have knowledge of all legislation, including minutes. Enclosed with the complaint was a copy of a note from the Council's legal service criticizing the Council's practice as regards statements for inclusion in the minutes of Council meetings.

The inquiry

In its comment on the complaint, the Council put forward three elements:

Firstly, it argued that the complaint did not come within the Ombudsman's remit. The Council's argument was that the complaint did not show that the Council's actions constituted maladministration and that the note from its legal service did not constitute proof of maladministration. The Council also stated that the complainant had referred the matter to the Ombudsman in his capacity as a Member of the European Parliament and that the complaint's desire for knowledge of all existing legislation was the expression of a political wish.

Secondly, the Council argued that the complainant had not made the necessary administrative approaches to the Council before he lodged his complaint with the European Ombudsman.

  • celex=31945D0026