, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

3.5 CASES OF MALADMINISTRATION LEADING TO DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE OMBUDSMAN

3.5.1 THE EUROPEAN ENVIRONMENT AGENCY

DISCLOSURE OF THE REASONS FOR REJECTING A CANDIDATE

Decision and recommendations in complaint 46/27.07.95/FVK/PD against the European Environment Agency

The complaint

By letter of 25 July 1995, Mrs von K. lodged a complaint with the European Ombudsman. In her complaint, Mrs von K. alleged that she had not been given reasons why she had failed in a selection procedure organized by the European Environment Agency for filling a post as project manager; furthermore, according to Mrs von K., her letters addressed to the Agency, asking for the reasons, had remained unanswered.

The inquiry

As the European Ombudsman did not take up his duties until 27 September 1995, he was not able to give immediate attention to the complaint. By letter of 27 March 1996, the Environment Agency forwarded its comments on the complaint. In its comments the Environment Agency gives information in relation to the procedure of the selection process. A translation of the comments was forwarded to Mrs von K., who submitted observations thereupon by fax of 27 May 1996. In her fax, Mrs. von K. communicated to the European Ombudsman that she would like to receive information about the selection criteria according to which the candidates were assessed and the actual profile of the successful candidate. Furthermore, Mrs. von K. questioned whether equal opportunities were provided for women in the selection procedure.

By letter of 2 July 1996, the European Ombudsman forwarded the complainant's observations to the Environment Agency and asked a number of questions regarding:

the criteria established by the selection committee, the qualification profile of the person who obtained the post for which Mrs. von K. had applied, information as to why Mrs. von K. never received a communication giving the reasons for not having been chosen for the post.

In its letter of 16 July 1996 responding to the European Ombudsman's request, the Environment Agency made the following points: The criteria used by the selection committee as well as the qualification profile of the person who obtained the post for which Mrs. von K. had applied were disclosed by the Environment Agency to the European Ombudsman and were to be dealt with confidentially. The Environment Agency met the necessary requirements to ensure equal treatment as regards to men and women.

The decision with recommendation