, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

Thirdly, the Council argued that on 2 October 1995 it had adopted a 'Code of Conduct on the publication of Council minutes and statements for inclusion in the minutes when the Council acts as a legislative authority, which shows that the Council has considerably changed its practice in this area. Since the adoption of the Code of Conduct, all statements for inclusion in the minutes of Council meetings in connection with the final adoption of legal acts within the meaning of the annex to the Council's rules of procedure have been made available to the public.`

The decision

As regards the Council's first argument, the Ombudsman pointed out that it is for the Ombudsman to decide whether a complaint is admissible. Community institutions and bodies are naturally welcome to make their views on the subject known to the Ombudsman.

When examining the admissibility of a complaint, it cannot be required that the complainant shall provide conclusive evidence of the maladministration complained of. In this context it has to be borne in mind that the Ombudsman's task is also to improve relations between Community institutions and European citizens; the office of Ombudsman was created in support of the Union's commitment to open, democratic and responsible administration. Requiring a citizen to provide evidence of maladministration when lodging a complaint would put an unreasonable burden on him and make it more difficult for him to have access to the Ombudsman. Nor does such a requirement seem to have any legal basis. It appears from the second paragraph of Article 138e (1) of the EC Treaty that the Ombudsman conducts enquiries into 'alleged facts` ('faits allégués` in French), not proven facts. Article 3 (1) of the Statute of the Ombudsman states that the Ombudsman may conduct enquiries into 'suspected maladministration` (cas éventuel de mauvaise administration' in French).

In the complaint, it was alleged that not all existing legislation was accessible. A note was attached as an integral part of the complaint. The note was extremely critical of the Council's practice as regards statements annexed to the minutes of Council meetings. The complaint thus clearly alleged that there had been maladministration.

  • abbr:eu=EC (the document of this name that we hold has no such provision)
  • celex=31923D0003