, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

2.10 The question therefore arises as to which stage of the administrative procedure under English law is to be regarded as the equivalent of 'the date when the application for consent was formally lodged.` In identifying such an equivalent it is important to recall that the Court of Justice in Großkrotzenburg expressly rejected a claim that a preliminary stage of the consent procedure, involving informal contacts and meetings between the competent authority and the developer, could be treated as a definite indication of the date on which the consent procedure was initiated.

2.11 Draft orders for the Newbury Bypass were published between 1986 and 1988; the public inquiry began on 14 June 1988 and closed on 9 November 1988; the final Statutory Instrument was made on 18 June 1991 and became effective on 16 August 1991.

2.12 The complainants argued that the publication of draft orders and the public inquiry were preliminary procedures for consultation and discussion of the Department of Transport's preferred route and alternative schemes. In their view, such procedures cannot be described as a formal application and are the equivalent of 'informal contacts and meetings between the competent authority and the developer`. According to the complainants, the equivalent of a formal application is the making of the final Statutory Instrument, which is followed by a six-week period within which it is subject to challenge in the High Court.

2.13 The Commission's position on this point is not entirely clear from the First Opinion, which states only that:

'Newbury Bypass was a pipeline case, in as much as the date of application for development consent preceded 3 July 1988, while the date of grant of development consent came later`; and

'The factual circumstances in respect of Newbury Bypass are that the consent procedure was initiated before 3 July 1988.`

The Commission does not, therefore, specify which point of the national procedures it regards as the equivalent of a formal application in the Newbury Bypass case. Logically, however, it must be either the publication of the draft orders or the opening of the public inquiry, since these are the only stages of the procedure that occurred before 3 July 1988.

  • celex=31985L0337