, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The Commission's comments to the Ombudsman stated that the Commission had received 29 projects from Member States which were examined in a meeting of experts in December 1994. The foundation project arrived at the Commission at the end of January.

The Commission also stated that it had decided that only seven projects and not one per member state should be examined further with a view to receiving Community funding, and this dependent on detailed examination following remarks by the experts.

In relation to the specific complaint, the Commission commented that Member States were informed of the results of the evaluation by a standard letter, the relevant paragraph of which said that the projects that were not selected did not meet the announced criteria. The Commission recognised that in the letter concerning the project of the foundation, this paragraph should have been replaced by a paragraph indicating that the project had arrived after the deadline and that its letter created the misleading impression that the project had been evaluated when in fact it had not.

The Commission further stated that, after complaint, it had corrected this error in its letter of 6 June 1995, which explained that all the Italian projects submitted including that of the foundation had arrived after the deadline and after the meeting of experts had taken place.

The Commission denied responsibility for the three week delay in the arrival in Italy of the letter of 4 October 1994 and stated that it considered that it had respected the published procedures and equality of treatment. The Commission stated, however, that in the light of this experience the Commission should in future envisage longer deadlines for submission of projects or, if the timetable does not permit this, to send letters by fax as well as by post.

In observations on the Commission's comments, the complainant specified that the foundation project was dispatched from Italy to the Commission on 28 November 1994. The complainant also argued that the Commission's comments indicated that even the seven successful projects were incomplete and that the principle of impartiality should therefore have led the Commission to reject these projects.