In cases where follow-up action by the Ombudsman does appear necessary (that is, more serious cases of maladministration, or cases that have general implications), the Ombudsman makes a decision with draft recommendations to the institution or body concerned. In accordance with Article 3 (6) of the Statute of the Ombudsman, the institution or body must send a detailed opinion within three months. The detailed opinion could consist of acceptance of the Ombudsman's decision and a description of the measures taken to implement the recommendations.
In 1996 the Ombudsman began 210 inquiries, 207 in relation to complaints and three own-initiatives.
Twelve cases were settled by the institution or body itself. Two further cases were dropped by the complainant. In 82 cases, the Ombudsman's inquiries revealed no instance of maladministration.
A critical remark was addressed to the institution in 32 cases. Recommendations to the institutions and bodies concerned were made in two cases, for both of which the three-month time-limit for a detailed opinion from the institution or body concerned expires in 1997. (See Annex A, Statistics, p. 50)
DECISIONS FOLLOWING AN INQUIRY
3.1 CASES WHERE NO MALADMINISTRATION WAS FOUND
3.1.1 THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT
TERMINATION OF A CONTRACT
Decision on complaint 11/3.1.95/DK/UK-EF-en against the European Parliament
The complaint
Mrs K. addressed a letter to the European Ombudsman on 5 December 1994 to complain that the European Parliament in Luxembourg had terminated her contract without notice because she had refused to sign inaccurate minutes of a meeting.
The inquiry
Once the first European Ombudsman had been elected, inquiries began. On 22 February 1996, the Ombudsman received comments on the complaint from the European Parliament. These were copied to the complainant on 8 March 1996 and she replied with observations on 12 March.
The decision
1) Findings on matters of law and possible scope of maladministration
1.1 The European Ombudsman did not accept the claim that there was a contract of employment between the complainant and the European Parliament. It is uncontested that the complainant had a contract with a company called T.C.S. Ltd., which in turn had a contract with the European Parliament. This contract appears to have been the legal basis of the work relationship between the complainant and the European Parliament.