, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

During the autumn of 1995 and the first months of 1996, the Ombudsman received a relatively large amount of complaints related to the nuclear tests that the French government announced in June 1995 it would start in French Polynesia. The complaints in substance put forward that the Commission had been passive in this respect.

The inquiry

In its first opinion on this matter the Commission drew the Ombudsman's attention to the fact that a number of individuals had brought a case before the Court of First Instance concerning the same subject-matter. It therefore gave no opinion on the merits of the complaints.

In order to be able to assess properly whether the Ombudsman under Articles 1.3 and 2.7 of the Statute should terminate his consideration of the complaints because of identity between the Court proceedings and the complaints, the Ombudsman requested the Commission to transmit to him a copy of the proceedings before the Court. The Commission did not forward the requested documentation and in the meantime, the applicants before the Court withdrew their action. Subsequently, the Commission presented comments on the merits of the complaints. The Commission stated in substance:

'All the complaints but one consider that the Commission has not correctly enforced Community law as to the nuclear testing in French Polynesia. Although most complaints do not specify which legal provisions have been breached, it may be considered that they all denounce the failure, from their point of view, of the European Commission to apply Article 34 of the Euratom Treaty to the current series of nuclear tests carried out by France.

It should firstly be made clear that, in spite of what is stated in some complaints, the opinion which the Commission is called upon to give at the request of a Member State under Article 34 of the Euratom Treaty bears not upon the advisability of carrying out a particularly dangerous experiment but upon the additional health and safety measures that the Member State concerned must take.

Although France had not made any submission under Article 34 of the Euratom Treaty concerning the new series of tests started in 1995, the Commission has, since their announcement in June 1995, sought to ensure that the provisions of the Treaty were fully respected.