, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

3.3 Given that this aspect of the case concerns procedures relating to specific events in the past, it is not necessary to make further inquiries or to pursue a friendly settlement of the matter.

In view of the above findings, the Ombudsman considered that it was unnecessary to conduct further inquiries into the case whilst trusting that the Commission would take note of the critical remark in paragraph 3.2. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

Further remarks by the Ombudsman

As noted in the Annual Report for 1995, an important part of the Ombudsman's mission is to enhance relations between the Community institutions and European citizens. The creation of the office of Ombudsman by the Treaty on European Union was meant to underline the commitment of the Union to open, democratic and accountable forms of administration.

The inquiries of the Ombudsman into the Newbury Bypass, and into several other complaints against the Commission, have led him to conclude that it is appropriate for there to be a more general examination of the procedural position of individual complainants in the Article 169 procedure.

On the basis of the complaints that the Ombudsman has received, it appears that the procedure currently used by the Commission causes considerable dissatisfaction amongst European citizens, some of whom regard the Commission's approach to the discharge of its responsibilities under Article 169 as arrogant and high-handed. Furthermore, the procedure appears not to promote the degree of transparency which European citizens increasingly expect in the functioning of Community institutions and bodies.

Without prejudice to the question of whether the principles of Community law might require more developed procedural rights for private complainants under Article 169, the Commission could itself decide to create such rights as a matter of good administrative behaviour, consistent with the case-law of the Court of Justice and Court of First Instance that individuals cannot challenge the Commission's decision not to open infringement proceedings.

In particular, before making its final decision, the Commission might communicate to registered complainants a provisional conclusion that there is no breach of Community law and its findings in support of that conclusion, with an invitation to submit observations within a defined period.