3) Newbury Bypass was a pipeline case, in as much as the date of application for development consent preceded 3 July 1988, while the date of grant of development consent came later.
The Directive contains no transitional provisions, and there is a point of interpretation as to whether its requirements apply to 'pipeline` cases.
The point of interpretation was touched upon in connection with two decisions of the Court of Justice (5). In both cases the Advocate-General argued that Member States may omit an environmental impact assessment for projects in respect of which the development consent procedure was initiated before 3 July 1988.
The Court itself did not explicitly state that the date of application/commencement of the development consent procedure was the decisive factor. However in the Großkrotzenburg case, the Court assessed the factual circumstances as to when a formal application was submitted. The latter would have been of no importance if the date of consent was the relevant factor. As a consequence of this jurisprudence, Directive 85/337/EEC is to be interpreted so as to exclude from its scope pipeline cases.
The factual circumstances in respect of Newbury Bypass are that the consent procedure was initiated before 3 July 1988. Therefore, the Commission considers that Directive 85/337/EEC did not apply to the Newbury Bypass project.
The complainants' observations on the First Opinion
Taking the observations sent to the Ombudsman as a whole, the following claims were made in relation to the First Opinion:
1) The Commission's remarks about its discretion amount to an assertion that it can act arbitrarily.
2) The Commission failed to answer the allegation that it had acted disingenuously.
3) The Commission continued to misinterpret the Großkrotzenburg case and failed to apply it correctly to the UK development procedures used in the Newbury Bypass case.
4) The Commission claimed that it had kept the complainants informed. However, it had informed the media of the decision to close the Newbury file in a press release dated 20th October 1995, while complainants were finally informed by letters dated 6th December 1995.
The decision
1) The Commission's decision
1.1 The Commission explained the decision to close the file in the Newbury Bypass case solely in terms of a legal conclusion that Directive 85/337/EEC does not apply to the Newbury Bypass project.