, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The Ombudsman found that there was no justification for the allegation that the Commission had been passive in the matter. Furthermore, he stated that he did not find on the basis of the elements put forward by the complainants that the Commission had exercised its powers wrongly or incompletely. Thus, as he had not found any instance of maladministration in the action of the Commission, the Ombudsman decided to close the cases.

METHOD OF ASSESSMENT OF LIEN PHARE-TACIS APPLICATIONS

Decision on complaint 52/27.7.95/JL/B against the European Commission

The complaint

Mr L. wrote to the Ombudsman concerning the rejection by the European Commission of projects he had submitted for funding through the LIEN Phare-Tacis 1994 programme of assistance to states of Central and Eastern Europe and the former USSR. The letter informing him of the rejection stated that the Commission is not obliged to justify its decisions. Mr L. said that, in fact, he received brief commentaries on the rejections on a standard form information sheet. He considered that this information was insufficient to enable weaknesses in the application to be addressed with a view to resubmission.

The complainant asked whether the administration possesses a standard assessment method for use in evaluating LIEN project applications and, if so why the results of the application of that method are not communicated to applicants.

The inquiry

Inquiries revealed that the process of selecting projects under the LIEN Phare-Tacis 1994 programme involved three stages:

1) screening and evaluation of proposals by a team of experts provided by the European Volunteer Centre/East European Partnership (CEV/EEP), a specialized company established in Brussels;

2) consideration of the recommendations by an Advisory Group of specialists drawn from various Directorates General of the Commission;

3) final selection by the Commission, acting upon the proposals from the Advisory Group. In 1994, 53 projects were accepted out of a total of 590 applications.

In its reply to the Ombudsman's requests for comments, the Commission said that an evaluation grid with detailed criteria and weightings is published in the documentation folder about LIEN. The reply also stated that the Advisory Group 'also takes considerations such as a fair geographical spread into account`.