, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

1.2 The absence of a contract of employment is not decisive of the question of maladministration. The treatment received by an individual working in the Parliament in the circumstances of the complainant could amount to maladministration.

2) Findings of fact

2.1 It was clear from the complaint and supporting documents, and from the inquiries that were conducted, that the working relationship between the complainant and the person who was the principal subject of her complaint, Mr B., had deteriorated before the events that eventually gave rise to the complaint. There was no evidence that this deterioration of the working relationship was the result of, or was accompanied by, maladministration.

2.2 The facts of the incident relating to the minutes were contested. There was no doubt about when and where various meetings took place and who was present, but there were differences of fact and interpretation between the various accounts, concerning what took place at those meetings and its significance. The Ombudsman found no evidence to suggest that this incident was caused by, or was in itself, an act of maladministration. It seemed unlikely that further inquiries could allow the Ombudsman to resolve the disputed issues in favour of the complainant.

In view of the above findings on matters of law and fact, the Ombudsman deci ded that no further inquiries were justified and closed the case.

3.1.2 THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION

NUCLEAR TESTS IN FRENCH POLYNESIA

Decision on complaints 34/21.7.95/PMK/EN, 148/28.9.95/BL/ES-DE, 215/07.11.95/FJRC/ES, 242/20.11.95/DS/UK-EN, 243/20.11.95/JF/UK-EN, 244/20.11.95/RSS/UK-EN, 246/22.11.95/JML/UK-EN, 247/22.11.95/HW/UK-EN, 248/22.11.95/DT/UK-EN, 250/22.11.95/GMA/UK-EN, 251/22.11.95/MG/UK-EN, 285/14.12.HNDG/PO-PO, 294/3.1.96/AB/UK-EN, 296/3.1.96/PS/UK-EN, 297/3.1.96/FDN/UK-EN, 299/12.1.96/APW/UK-EN, 301/13.12.95/PB/UK-EN, 323/4.1.96/JM/UK-EN, 326/8.1.96/WMC/UK-EN, 329/8.1.96/CG/UK-EN, 341/8.1.96/JB/UK-EN, 342/8.1.96/RN/UK-EN, 343/8.1.96/CRJ/UK-EN, 344/8.1.96/MD/UK-EN, 345/13.12.95/PM/UK-EN, 351/11.1.96/PLT/UK-EN, 352/10.1.96/DP/UK-EN, 353/10.1.96/RW/UK-EN, 368/16.1.96/MO/UK-EN, 369/16.1.96/DH/UJ-EN, 370/16.1.96/RB/UK-EN, 375/18.1.96/LF/UK-EN, 379/26.1.96/PE/UK-EN, 380/25.1.96/AS/UK-EN, 386/22.1.96/AH/UK-EN, 399/31.1.96/J& J/UK-EN, 410/7.2.96/EHW/UK-EN, 440/20.2.96/AW/UK-EN against the European Commission

The complaints

  • celex=31911D0003
  • celex=31934D0021