, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

Following consideration of the Commission's comments and the complainant's observations, the Ombudsman asked the Commission for further information on a number of questions. The replies indicated that the meeting between the Commission and the experts took place on 15 December 1994 and that the foundation project was received by DG XVI on 20 December 1994, but because of the end of year holidays it was not transmitted to the relevant service until January 1995. The Commission also stated that it had received on 16 November 1994 the letter from the Italian Ministry of the Budget and Economic Planning dated 2 November 1994.

The decision

1) The short deadline and postal delays

1.1 In an administrative procedure involving the submission and consideration of applications, it is for the Commission to determine if a deadline is necessary and if so what it should be.

1.2 The deadline of 31 October established in the Commission's letter dated 4 October was not manifestly unreasonable. There do not appear to be any grounds for the accusation that DG XVI foresaw postal delays and made use of them in order to discriminate between member states.

1.3 Where a very short deadline is established, it is good administrative practice to consider whether post alone is an adequate means of communication to those who are invited to submit applications.

1.4 If fax had also been used as means of communication in this case, the administrative process would have been more effective in that many subsequent problems and suspicions could have been avoided.

1.5 The Commission has acknowledged that, in future, deadlines should be longer and, if this is not possible, fax should be used as a complementary mode of communication. In view of this acknowledgement no further remark by the Ombudsman is necessary.

2) The Commission's failure to respond to the letter of 2 November 1994

2.1 According to the Commission, the letter of 2 November 1994 from Dr De Dominicis to Mr Landáburu requesting more time arrived on 16 November 1994. It appears from the Commission's replies to the Ombudsman that this letter received neither acknowledgement nor an answer.

2.2 It is normal that letters addressed to the administration should receive a reply. The failure to answer the request for more time was, therefore, maladministration.