The Commission's letter informing the complainants of its decision, as well as being unduly delayed, gave no reasons for the conclusion that there was no infringement of the Directive. The Ombudsman has already noted in his decision of 29 October 1996 on the complaints against the European Commission concerning the Newbury Bypass (206/27.10.95/HS/UK and others) that an administrative process of this kind normally concludes with a reasoned decision communicated to those who have participated in the process.
Had reasons been given, the complainants would have learnt that their assumptions were mistaken in 1992, or earlier, rather than in 1996. Because they did not know the reason why their complaint had been rejected, the complainants directed their energies in the matter - understandably and reasonably - first to finding out what the United Kingdom authorities had said to the Commission and then, following the investigation by the UK Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, to the way their complaint had been dealt with by the Commission. In the event, both these lines of enquiry were bound to be fruitless. It would not be surprising if the complainants were left with a sense of grievance as a result of their participation in the Article 169 procedure.
The further remarks of the Ombudsman in the present case will be taken into account in an own-initiative inquiry into the procedural position of complainants to the Commission in the Article 169 procedure.
The Ombudsman closed the case with the critical remark in paragraph 4.3 of the decision.
FAILURE TO ANSWER A REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF A TIME LIMIT
Decision on complaint 154/02.10.95/SF/IT against the European Commission
The complaint
The President of an Italian foundation complained about the European Commission's rejection of an urban renovation project which the Italian authorities had submitted for funding from the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF).