, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The blue flag system is organized by a non-governmental organization based in Denmark, the Foundation for Environmental Education in Europe, which is also responsible for making awards. The Commission therefore has no say in the award of blue flags. It does, however, play a part in the process, since it provides information on one of the basic criteria for the award of a blue flag, namely the quality of bathing waters.

The Commission forwarded the complaint to the Foundation and asked the Foundation's national operator to provide information on the circumstances under which a blue flag had been awarded to the beach in question.

At the same time, the Commission initiated infringement proceedings against Portugal, pursuant to Article 169 of the Treaty, for alleged manipulation of the results of tests on water samples (breach of Directive 76/160/EEC on bathing waters).

No evidence of fraudulent use of Community funds by the Portuguese authorities emerged from the inquiries conducted by the Commission.

Therefore, in view of the fact that a blue flag had not been awarded to the beach at Armaçao de Pêra for 1996, and of the action which, within the limits of its powers, the Commission had taken vis-à-vis the authorities and organizations responsible, it was felt that a satisfactory response had been given to the legitimate questions raised by Mr C. in his complaint.

Following Mr C.'s decision to withdraw his complaint, the European Ombudsman decided not to conduct further enquiries and closed the case.

LATE SETTLEMENT OF AN INVOICE

Decision on complaint 236/17. 11. 1995/AKH/KT-en against the European Commission

A company which had entered a contract with the European Commission lodged a complaint in November 1995 concerning the late settlement of an invoice within the framework of the Tacis Danube Environmental Programme. The invoice had been sent to the Commission in February 1994 but was not settled until several months later, despite a contractual payment period of 30 days.

The European Ombudsman asked the Commission for its comments. In its reply, the Commission considered that the payment to the company had been made later than was reasonable and that interest should be paid.

The Commission's reply was sent to the complainant. The company was willing to accept an apology from the Commission, together with an offer to pay interest on the overdue amount.