On 20 October 1995, the Commission issued a press release saying that, in the light of the decision of the European Court of Justice in the Großkrotzenburg case (4), it had decided to interpret the Directive as requiring an environmental impact assessment only for projects where the procedure for consent was started after 3 July 1988. The press release further stated that this meant that the Directive did not apply to the Newbury Bypass.
The Commission subsequently wrote to the people whose complaints it had registered, stating that it had completed its investigation and had decided to close the file, since no breaches of Community law had been found. The complainants were referred to the press release for a more detailed explanation.
The complaints
Taking the complaints sent to the Ombudsman as a whole, four main claims were made concerning the Commission's decision to close the file:
1) The Commission had deprived citizens of the benefit of an authoritative ruling from the Court of Justice on the disputed issues of Community law involved and risked subverting the role of the Court
2) According to some complainants, the Commission's interpretation of the Directive was disingenuous, in that it was motivated by political considerations, or was the result of political pressure
3) The correct interpretation of the Großkrotzenburg case supported the view that the Directive applies to the Newbury Bypass
4) The Commission should have informed the registered complainants of its decision to close the file before announcing it through a press release
The inquiry
The First Opinion of the Commission
In its First Opinion, the Commission argued as follows:
1) The subject matter of the complaints involves the exercise by the Commission of its discretion with regard to proceedings under Article 169. In deciding not to open infringement proceedings, the Commission exercised its discretion as fully recognised by the Court.
2) The Commission proceeded vis-à-vis the complainants in accordance with the principles of good administrative behaviour by duly registering the complaints and keeping the complainants informed of the treatment of the case. Complainants in an Article 169 procedure do not possess any specific procedural rights as could be the case in other sectors like competition or anti-dumping. The Commission therefore sees no grounds for any complaint of maladministration in such a case.