, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The rules regarding the secondment of national experts have been laid down - by the Commission - in a Decision of 26 July 1988. The procedure for the secondment of national experts is of another nature than the procedure for the filling of posts reserved for the successful candidates of a competition. The same is applicable to the temporary staff posts. The policy of the Commission not to give preference to candidates on the reserve list when seeking to fill such posts does therefore not appear questionable.

Article 5 of Annex III of the Staff Regulations, contains the obligation to include more candidates on the reserve list than the number of recruitments expected. The Commission can thus be understood in its reasoning that a successful candidate of a competition does not have the right to be recruited.

The Commission has the right to extend the validity of a specific reserve list. When the profile of the posts expected to be available in the future is different from the profile for which the competition was held, a renewal of the validity of the list can seem unjustified. In the case of the reserve list for competition COM/A/730, the Commission's service particularly concerned by the reserve list had been consulted before the decision on the extension of the validity of the list was taken.

From this point of view, the decision not to extend the validity of the reserve list for competition COM/A/730 beyond 31 December 1994, even though it still contained two successful candidates, does not seem to go contrary to the general principles of good administrative behaviour.

In view of these findings and taking into account that the Commission had apologized for the failure to reply to the letter of 30 January 1995, the Ombudsman reached the conclusion that there was no instance of maladministration and closed the case.

ACCESS TO INFORMATION ON COMMISSION PROGRAMMES

Decision on complaint 104/1.9.95/IDS/B/PD against the European Commission

The complaint

Mr B., of French nationality, lodged a complaint with the European Ombudsman against the European Commission. He stated that for almost one year he had been trying to obtain a list by country of the institutions and associations which had received support from the European Social Fund under the training programmes for the disabled between 1981 and 1994.

The inquiry

  • celex=31969D0016