, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

The complainant had submitted in May 1995 an application for a grant under the Community Programme for Training and Mobility of Researchers, in answer to a Call for Proposals which had been published in the Official Journal on 17 January 1995. This Programme was adopted by the Council on 15 December 1994 and its aim was to enhance mobility of researchers. The Commission was responsible for the implementation of the Programme.

A condition for receiving a grant under the programme is that the researcher does not hold the nationality of the country where he intends to undertake the research for which the grant is given.

The complainant had both Portuguese and French nationalities and applied for a grant in order to undertake research at the 'Instituto de Biologia Experimental e Tecnologica` in Portugal. The complainant stated that before applying, she addressed the Commission by letter of 17 January 1995 in order to know how the Commission would apply the nationality condition to holders of more than one nationality in a situation like hers. She did not receive any answer to this request for information. By letter of 12 July 1995, the Commission replied to her application. It informed her that she was not eligible for the grant as she held the nationality of the country of the research institution.

The complainant addressed the Commission in August and September 1995 in order to make the Commission change the decision taken. She put forward that the Commission's application of the nationality condition to plurinationals was wrong. In its answers, the Commission apologized that it had not earlier provided more precise information about the application of the nationality condition to plurinationals; it stated that the application made was in conformity with the practice developed under previous programmes and that the Commission subsequently had adopted an explicit rule addressing the situation of plurinationals which endorsed the practice developed. The Commission thus maintained its decision.

In the complaint, the complainant said that she was never properly informed about the way the Commission would apply the nationality condition to plurinationals, as the Commission had never replied to her request for information and that there was no legal basis for the Commission's application. In any case, she considered the Commission's application to be unfair.

The inquiry

  • celex=31992R3904