2.4 The Ombudsman notes that in other contexts, including its reply to the Committee on Petitions concerning petitions 865/95 and 972/95, the Commission also referred to the general unwritten principle of legal certainty and the principles of legitimate expectations and proportionality in support of its interpretation.
2.5 The Commission's interpretation of the Directive has been criticized by the complainants and by some commentators (6). The criticisms point out that, in Großkrotzenburg, the Court of Justice expressly left open the question of the application of the Directive to 'pipeline` cases (paragraph 28 of the judgement) and that the principles of legal certainty and legitimate expectations also provide arguments against the Commission's interpretation.
2.6 The Ombudsman considers it regrettable that the First Opinion contains only a very brief, and possibly incomplete, outline of the Commission's legal reasoning in support of its conclusion that the Directive does not apply to 'pipeline` cases.
2.7 The Ombudsman does not consider, however, that the conclusion itself is wrong as a matter of law. In view of the opinions of the Advocates-General in Bund Naturschutz and Großkrotzenburg and the fact that the Court of Justice in Großkrotzenburg evaluated the factual circumstances as to when a formal application was submitted, the conclusion that Directive 85/337/EEC does not apply to 'pipeline` cases is probably correct. It must be recalled, however, that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.
2.8 As regards the second stage of the argument, and subject to the qualification in the last sentence of paragraph 2.7, the Ombudsman considers that, prima facie, the appropriate criterion to identify 'pipeline` cases is that used in Großkrotzenburg: i.e. the date when the application for consent was formally lodged.
2.9 The legal procedures in England for development consent in the case of highway projects do not involve an application for development consent by one body to another. The procedure is an administrative one, in which both the developer and the authority which grants development consent are parts of the central government administration.