The decision
As it appeared from the Commission's comments that it recognized that there had been a misunderstanding in this case and that it had taken measures in order to avoid such misunderstandings in the future, the Ombudsman considered that there were no grounds to proceed further with the complaints. Thus, he closed the case.
RIGHTS OF PERSONS ON RESERVE LIST
Decision on complaint 71/16.08.95/JD/B against the European Commission
The complaint
On 1 August 1995, Mr D. lodged a complaint with the European Ombudsman, concerning the reserve list of competition COM/A/730 in which he had participated successfully in 1991. He complained that the reserve list of competition COM/A/730 had not been extended beyond 31 December 1994, that the Commission had hired national experts while the reserve list was still full and that he had received no reply to his letter when he had brought this matter to the attention of the Commission.
The inquiry
On 13 December 1995, the Ombudsman forwarded the complaint to the European Commission asking the Commission to comment on it. The Commission gave its first opinion on 27 March 1996. It was forwarded to the complainant on 30 April 1996.
According to the Commission, the decision not to extend the reserve list beyond 31 December 1994 was based on the number of recruitments from the list (only 2 candidates had remained) and the type of profile which was considered necessary in the future.
Concerning the secondment of national experts, the Commission found that this serves a specific purpose. It is not solely to allow the Commission to take advantage of the expertise and knowledge of such national civil servants but also to reach a better mutual understanding between the European and national administrations. Therefore it is completely understandable that national experts are not chosen from the successful candidates in a competition. Finally, the Commission apologized for the failure to reply to the letter of 30 January 1995, and stated that it will make sure that such mistakes in comparable cases are not made in the future.
The complainant gave his observations on the findings of the Commission on 13 September 1996. He considered that when assessing the policy of the Commission with regard to the secondment of national experts, it should be taken into consideration that the national expert in question had been recruited as temporary staff following this contract as a national expert.
The decision