However, the Ombudsman noted that the complainant had received the report he had applied for access to, as the Secretary-General of the Commission had rectified the mistake made. In view of this and the fact that the Secretary-General, when replying to the Ombudsman's requests for information, had openly acknowledged the mistake on the Commission's behalf and that the Commission would in the future make every effort to prevent any recurrence of such mistakes, the Ombudsman found no grounds for further consideration of the complaint. He therefore closed the case.
CONFIDENTIALITY OF INFORMATION ABOUT NUCLEAR MATERIALS
Decision on complaint 186/16.10.95/DL/UK/KT against the European Commission
The complaint
In October 1995 Mr L. wrote to the European Ombudsman to complain about the answers given by the European Commission to two written parliamentary questions relating to nuclear materials.
The complainant could see no justification for the Commission to invoke the secrecy clause of Article 194 of the Euratom Treaty in its answers to the questions as a reason for not divulging information on depleted uranium stocks or on supply contracts for nuclear installations. He asked the Ombudsman to press the Commission to act in a spirit of openness and to release the information requested.
The inquiry
The Ombudsman asked for the Commission's comments on the complaint.
The comments of the Commission
As to the first question, the Commission quoted Article 194 of the Euratom Treaty as a reason not to disclose information on stocks of depleted uranium at certain sites in the United Kingdom. Once a Member State had classified certain information as subject to a security system, the Commission considered itself to be bound by that classification and to be required to keep such information secret.
As to the second question relating to commercial information about a supply contract for a nuclear installation in the Community, the Commission also referred to Article 194 of the Euratom Treaty and Regulations made thereunder as the reason for not divulging such commercial information. This information had been communicated to the Commission by the operators in accordance with Chapter VI of the Euratom Treaty at the time of negotiation, but remained the property of those operators.
The complainant's observations on the Commission's comments