, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

According to the observations of the complainant, the Commission should reconsider its insistence on secrecy because both Article 194 of the Euratom Treaty and the Regulations made thereunder were decided upon in two completely different political contexts. The Cold War and nuclear espionage were real threats and self-evidently the situation had changed since.

The decision

Since the Commission referred in both cases to Article 194, the issue of the secrecy clause was dealt with at the same time for both parliamentary questions.

Article 194 provides that:

'The members of the institutions of the Community (. . .) who (. . .) are called upon to acquire (. . .) information (. . .) which are subject to a security system in accordance with provisions laid down by a Member State (. . .) shall be required (. . .) to keep them secret from any unauthorized person and from the general public.`

It seems clear from the letter and the spirit of Article 194 that its provisions are binding for the institutions of the European Community, which are required to keep secret any information which is subject to a security system in accordance with provisions laid down by a Member State.

In the present case, the Commission confirmed its replies to Question E-1805/95 asked by Mr Alex Smith and Question E-1518/95 asked by Mrs Ahern that the Member State concerned had classified the information requested as 'subject to a security system' and that it was therefore not at liberty to release it.

As far as Mrs Ahern's question (E-1518/95) is concerned, it follows two other questions by Mrs Breyer on a supply contract for the Garchin nuclear reactor. The Commission invoked a second argument relating to the confidentiality of commercial information. It quoted a number of provisions, all of which emphasize the protection of commercial information considering that, as the information requested was the property of two economic operators acting in their commercial capacity, the Commission was not able to divulge such commercial information. It suggested that the Honourable Member request the information directly from the operators concerned.

In its comments to the Ombudsman of 21 May 1996, the Commission explained that: