In accordance with Chapter VI of the Euratom Treaty (. . .) the operators would communicate to the Agency commercial information, including the contract itself for conclusion. This information is and remains the property of those operators. The services of the Commission are not able to divulge such commercial information which is the property of the operators concerned.'
In order to determine the lawfulness of this argument, one has to examine the conditions under which the public has access to documents held by the Commission. The issue is settled by Commission Decision of 8 February 1994 on public access to Commission documents.
This decision establishes the principle of wide access of the public to Commission documents, while taking into account certain derogations relating to the protection of public interest or privacy.
It provides in the annexed Code of Conduct concerning public access to Commission and Council documents that:
'The institutions will refuse access to any document where disclosure could undermine:
. . .
the protection of commercial and industrial secrecy
. . .`
It appears therefore that the Commission's attitude, by answering that the information requested cannot be divulged because of the protection of commercial secrecy and by advising the Honourable Members to request such information directly from the operator concerned, is in accordance with its Decision of 8 February 1994.
In view of these findings, the European Ombudsman found no instance of maladministration in the Commission's attitude in this case. He therefore decided that no further inquiries were justified and closed the case.
MEASURES TAKEN AFTER ABOLITION OF CUSTOMS OPERATIONS AT BORDERS
Decision on complaint 189/18.10.95/SP/GR/KT against the European Commission
The complaint
In October 1995 Mr P. lodged a complaint against the European Commission with the European Ombudsman. After the abolition of borders in the European Union in January 1993, he had been obliged to close his customs clearing office and had suffered big financial losses. He considered that he should receive financial compensation. Moreover, the European Commission had not answered his letter of 5 November 1993.
The inquiry
The Ombudsman asked for the Commission's comments on the complaint.
In its reply, the European Commission considered that it was not for the Community to meet the responsibilities of the Member States and of the profession concerned, owing to the principle of subsidiarity.