, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

According to the Commission, the complainant had not executed the contract properly within the prescribed time frame. Therefore, he had not been paid. The Commission however felt that it could reach a settlement with the complainant and proposed to pay half of the payment due in execution of the contract. This, under the condition that the source code of the software developed by the complainant would not be used or developed further at any time and condition by him.

The Ombudsman sent the proposal made by the Commission to the complainant on several occasions, but did not receive any reply.

The Ombudsman then contacted the Commission requesting information on whether the Commission had paid the amount it had offered. He was informed that the payment had not yet taken place since the Commission had not received the approval of the conditions to which it was subject.

The decision

Considering the suggestion for settlement offered to the complainant by the Commission and taking into consideration that the complainant had not given any reply thereto, even after repeated inquiries, the Ombudsman decided to stop any further consideration of the complaint and closed the case.

3.4 CASES CLOSED WITH A CRITICAL REMARK

3.4.1 THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT

OPEN COMPETITION: LOSS OF CANDIDATE'S LETTER

Decision on complaint 145/27.9.95/ABMG/B-de against the European Parliament

Mrs M. G. asked the European Ombudsman to inform her about her rights to obtain a review of the marks which she had received in a general competition organised by the European Parliament. Mrs. M. G. did not succeed in the written tests and sent a letter to the selection board asking that it should reconsider its evaluation of her exam papers. The complainant stated that a second evaluation never took place.

In its comments, the European Parliament informed the European Ombudsman that the letter of the complainant had been wrongly addressed - to the Chairman of the selection board, and not to the Service 'Competition` - and that therefore, it could not be located. When the complainant had addressed the Parliament again, the selection board had already finished its work and handed in its report, and therefore her marks were not reviewed.

  • celex=31992L0049