In its second comments, the Commission acknowledged that it had not adhered to the deadlines for processing applications laid down in its decision of 8 February 1994 and stated that in the future it would make every effort to meet the deadlines. As regards the reason given for the original refusal of the application, the Commission acknowledged that it was invalid in pursuance of the decision.
The decision
The Ombudsman remarked that Article 1 of the Commission decision of 8 February 1994 on public access to Commission documents lays down that the joint Commission and Council code of conduct of 31 December 1993 on public access to documents is applicable to the Commission. Consequently, access to documents may be refused in order to protect the public interest (public security, international relations, monetary stability, court proceedings, inspections and investigations), the individual and privacy, commercial and industrial secrecy, the Community's financial interests, classified information and the confidentiality of Commission proceedings.
Article 2 of the decision lays down the procedure for obtaining access to documents: the Commission must inform the applicant within one month whether the application is granted or not. Where access cannot be granted, the applicant must be informed that he has one month in which to complain about the refusal. Failure to reply to an application for access within one month constitutes refusal of access and failure to reply within one month to an application for review also constitutes refusal. Against this background, the Ombudsman concluded that there were no grounds for regarding a failure to reply as acceptance of an application for access.
As to the grounds given for refusing the application for access, the Ombudsman remarked that they were not included in the list of considerations which in the Commission's decision of 8 February 1994 can justify refusing an application. He therefore regarded the refusal as unwarranted and incorrect.