Mrs. K. said that she took steps to comply with this condition. She obtained a certificate from her University (the University of Helsinki), dated 24 March 1995. This confirmed that she had completed all the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts. The certificate was on the headed paper of the Faculty of Arts, bore its official stamp and was signed by the Secretary of the Faculty. It was accompanied by an official stamped transcript of the courses she had taken and the credits and marks received. She submitted this certificate before 6 Arpil 1995, which was the time limit fixed by the notice of competition.
Her degree was formally conferred in a solemn ceremony held at the University on 30 May 1995.
The Selection Board wrote to Mrs. K. in July 1995. They excluded her from the competition, on the grounds that she had not provided a diploma or certificate to show that she had completed her University studies. The Selection Board took the view that only a document conferred at a solemn ceremony met the condition in the notice of competition.
Mrs. K. made three administrative approaches to the Council in an unsuccessful attempt to get the Selection Board to change its decision. She wrote to the Ombudsman on 11 September 1995 to complain that she should not have been excluded from the competition. She claimed that the certificate she had submitted met the requirements of the notice of competition.
The inquiry
The Ombudsman wrote to the Secretary General of the Council to ask for comments on the complaint. The reply from the Council made the following points:
it is established by case-law that the terms of a notice of competition are strictly binding on the Selection Board;
the Selection Board is only required to take into account documentary evidence that the candidates must submit before the deadline fixed in the notice of competition. The Selection Board is not required to ask candidates for documentary evidence which they have failed to transmit nor to take account of documents supplied after the deadline;
in the case of Mrs. K., the 'provisional certificate` dated 24 March 1995 could not be treated as a diploma or certificate confirming a completed course of study at a University;
documents attached to subsequent correspondence from Mrs. K. to the Selection Board could not be taken into account because they were sent outside the deadline;
Mrs. K. was therefore rightly eliminated from the competition.