2.14 In the Ombudsman's view, the publication of the draft orders can reasonably be regarded as the equivalent of a formal planning application, in that the developer makes a public statement containing definite proposals for development, which may then be the subject of a public inquiry. The fact that there may be differences between the draft order and the final project does not affect this conclusion, since there may also be changes made to an application during the course of the procedure for granting development consent. The possibility of such changes in both cases is inherent in the fact that the procedures involved are more than a mere formality.
2.15 Although it is regrettable that the First Opinion does not contain all the legal reasoning necessary to support the Commission's view that Newbury Bypass is a 'pipeline` case, the Ombudsman does not consider, therefore, that the conclusion itself contains an error in the application of Community law to the facts and the national legal context of the Newbury Bypass case.
2.16 The Ombudsman's inquiries into the complaints concerning the Newbury Bypass have not, therefore, revealed any instance of maladministration by the Commission in the interpretation of Community law, or in the application of Community law to the facts and to the national legal context of the case.
3) The failure to inform the registered complainants before issuing the press release
3.1 The Commission has invited individuals to submit to it complaints about breaches of Community law by Member States and has published a standard form for this purpose (7). In its First Opinion, the Commission acknowledges procedural obligations duly to register complaints and to keep the complainants informed of the treatment of the case.
3.2 An administrative process of this kind normally concludes with a reasoned decision communicated to those who have participated in the process. The Ombudsman considers that, as a matter of good administrative behaviour, the Commission should have informed the registered complainants of its decision before, or at least at the same time as, announcing the decision publicly through a press release. There may have been practical reasons why this was not possible in this particular case (although no such reasons have been advanced by the Commission in its First Opinion). If so, the Commission should at least have explained those reasons to the complainants.