Such a procedure could have two advantages over the present position. First, it might contribute towards more effective administration, by creating an opportunity for the Commission to receive criticisms of its views in time for it to evaluate and respond to those criticisms before committing itself to a final conclusion. Second, it could enhance relations between European citizens and the Commission, by allowing citizens to participate more fully in the administrative procedure under Article 169 and by improving the transparency of the Commission's activities.
The Ombudsman therefore decided to begin an own-initiative inquiry into this matter.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION'S HANDLING OF A COMPLAINT ABOUT AN ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT: M40 MOTORWAY
Decision on complaint 132/21.9.95/AH/EN against the European Commission
On 18 September 1995 Mr A. and Mr H. made a joint complaint against the European Commission. The complaint concerned the way in which the Commission had dealt with a complaint that it had received from Mr A. and Mr H. in relation to the widening of the M40 motorway in the United Kingdom.
The complaint to the European Commission
On 29 November 1990 Mr A. and Mr H. made a complaint to the European Commission alleging that the United Kingdom authorities had failed to comply with Directive 85/337/EEC (8) in relation to the widening of the M40 motorway. They alleged that a full and accurate environmental assessment of the proposed development was not carried out in accordance with the requirements of the Directive. The complaint made the following specific claims concerning the environmental assessment:
1) the noise level assessment was not carried out in accordance with the United Kingdom Department of Transport Manual of Environmental Appraisal;
2) the noise level assessment was not produced at the public consultation meetings;
3) a charge was made for a copy of the document containing the noise level assessment;
4) no air quality checks were made.
On 26 August 1991, the Commission acknowledged receipt of the complaint.