, Annual report 1996 - The European Ombudsman

In forcesince 21 Apr 1997

". . .it is clear from the scheme of Article 169 of the EEC Treaty that the Commission has no obligation to commence proceedings under that article; it has a discretionary power precluding the right of individuals to require it to adopt a particular position and to bring an action for annulment against its refusal to take action."

In deciding not to open infringement proceedings in the present case, the Commission exercised its discretion as fully recognised by the Court. Moreover, it has proceeded vis-à-vis the complainants in accordance with the principles of good administrative behaviour by duly registering the complaints and keeping the complainants informed on the treatment of the case. It should be added that complainants in a 169 EC procedure do not possess any specific procedural rights as could be the case in other sectors like competition or anti-dumping. The Commission therefore sees no grounds for any complaint of maladministration in such a case.`

The Commission also asked the Ombudsman to take a position on the admissibility of the complaint, in view of the requirement of Article 2 (4) of the Statute of the Ombudsman that a complaint must be made within two years of the date on which the facts on which it is based came to the attention of the person lodging the complaint.

The further inquiries

After careful examination of the Commission's comments, it appeared that the main questions raised by the complaint to the Ombudsman remained unanswered.

To avoid fruitless debate on the two-year time limit, the Ombudsman decided to conduct further inquiries on his own initiative, in accordance with Article 138e of the Treaty and Article 3 (1) of the Statute of the Ombudsman. He asked the Commission:

1) what steps it took to deal with the complaint from Mr A. and Mr H.;

2) what material formed the basis of the Commission's conclusion that there had been no infringement of Directive 85/337/EEC;

3) what correspondence was exchanged between the Commission and the UK authorities regarding the case?

The Commission's reply

The reply from the Commission included information about

1) its interpretation of Directive 85/337/EEC;

2) its view of the principles on which it should act in cases of this kind;

3) an account of how it dealt with the complaint.

As regards the interpretation of the Directive, the Commission referred to provisions of Article 5 that require information to be supplied only where the Member State considers certain conditions to be fulfilled.