By letter of 12 January 1996, the complainant informed the Ombudsman that the dispute between the institute and the Commission had been settled and that the complaint was withdrawn.
The Ombudsman took note that the case had been solved in a mutually satisfactory way and closed the case.
AWARD OF A BLUE FLAG, A MARK OF CLEANLINESS, TO A BEACH
Decision on complaint 235/16.11.95/JMC-fr against the European Commission
The complaint
In November 1995 Mr C. lodged a complaint concerning the award of a blue flag, which is a mark of a beach's quality and cleanliness, to the beach at Armaçao de Pêra in the Algarve, Portugal, and the use of ERDF funds for the beach.
The complainant considered that the blue flag had been unjustly awarded, given the harmful effects which the beach had on the environment and health. He attached several photographs to his complaint, illustrating the deplorable condition of the approaches to the beach and the quantity of refuse which had built up there. He also questioned the use made by the Portuguese authorities of the Community funds allocated for the protection of the beach.
The inquiry
The European Ombudsman informed the European Commission that a blue flag had been awarded to the beach at Armaçao de Pêra and asked it to comment on the matter.
In its reply, the Commission pointed out that it was not directly responsible for the award of blue flags, which was coordinated by a non-governmental organization based in Denmark. Its only role was to provide information on one of the criteria used in the selection process. It had, nonetheless, asked the non-governmental organization to provide further information, and undertook to forward a report on its inquiry to the complainant.
The Commission stated that it had found no evidence of fraud in connection with the Community funds.
The Ombudsman forwarded these comments to Mr C., who expressed satisfaction with the action taken by the Ombudsman, given that a blue flag had not been awarded to the beach at Armaçao de Pêra for 1996, and withdrew his complaint. He also asked to be sent the inquiry report referred to above.
The Ombudsman also attached a copy of a letter from the Commissioner, Mrs Ritt BJERREGAARD, stating that, pursuant to Article 169 of the Treaty, the Commission had initiated proceedings against the Portuguese authorities for breach of the relevant Community legislation, in particular Directive 76/160/EEC (bathing waters).
The decision