The case was thus solved in a satisfactory manner for the complainant and the European Ombudsman decided to close the case.
THE DIRECTIVE ON NON-LIFE INSURANCE
Decision on complaints 256/23.11.95/EA//B-FR, 291/21.12.95/SA/B-FR and 311/4.1.96/CN/B-FR against the European Commission
The complaint
The complaints focus on the interpretation by the European Commission of Directive 92/49/EEC on non-life insurance.
In October 1995 an insurance company based in France notified its clients in Belgium (the complainants) of its decision to cease to provide insurance cover for persons resident abroad 'owing to the Community provisions on freedom to provide services`. This action had been prompted by the entry into force on 1 July 1994 of the third insurance directives and the legal requirements deriving therefrom. The complainants therefore wrote to the European Ombudsman about the Commission's interpretation of these Community directives, which they deemed to be the cause of the termination of their insurance policies.
The inquiry
The Ombudsman notified the Commission, which forwarded its comments on the matter.
The Commission first outlined the legal provisions governing the taking up and pursuit of the business of insurance which were laid down in the directives. It then explained the situation in some Member States prior to the entry into force of the directives and, lastly, set out the Commission's position on the complaints lodged.
The complainants had no observations to make on the Commission's comments, and simply thanked the Ombudsman for his efforts on their behalf.
The decision
Prior to the entry into force of the insurance directives some Member States, including Belgium, prohibited insurance companies based in another Member State from providing cover for risks on their territories if they were not established there. Companies failing to comply with this requirement could be penalized, inter alia by means of the invalidation of policies.
Under this system, the contract between the complainants and their company had no legal certainty if the insurer failed to meet this requirement.
The third insurance directives seek to put an end to this situation, which conflicts with the principle of freedom to provide services in the insurance field, by enabling any insurer based in a Member State to provide cover for risks in another Member State, without having to be established there.