3.3 It therefore appears that all four claims made by the complainants raised issues within the area of judgement left by the Directive to Member States. On the basis of the Commission's analysis of its own role, it therefore appears that there would have been no basis for further action under Article 169, even assuming that the complainants were right in all four claims that they made. Therefore a detailed investigation of the claims was unnecessary and the Commission was entitled to limit its inquiry to the documents which it requested from the UK authorities and to base its decision to close the file on those documents.
3.4 The Ombudsman's inquiries have not, therefore, revealed any instance of maladministration by the Commission in the application of Community law to the facts of the case.
4) Undue delay
4.1 The original complaint to the Commission was made on 29 November 1990. Receipt of the complaint was acknowledged on 26 August 1991. The Commission has already apologised for this delay, which was clearly too long, and no further remark by the Ombudsman seems necessary.
4.2 From the examination of the documents, it is clear that there was delay of over nine months between the date when the Commission decided to close the file and the communication of this decision to the complainants. Since the date of the decision was not specified in the letter to the complainants, they were unaware of the delay.
4.3 As a matter of good administrative practice, the Commission should always communicate a decision to close a file to the complainant reasonably promptly. There appears to have been no justification for the delay in this case. However, there is no evidence that the delay was the result of anything other than an administrative failure.
Further remarks by the Ombudsman
The complaints to the European Commission, to the UK Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration and to the European Ombudsman were all based on the assumption that, if the four specific claims concerning the environmental assessment of the M40 project were correct, then the UK authorities had necessarily failed to comply with the requirements of Directive 85/337/EEC. The complainants therefore also assumed that the Commission had a duty to investigate their four claims in detail.
These assumptions - though understandable - were mistaken, for the reasons given above.