In its comments on the complaint, the Commission stated that it had no record in its files of any request for information previous to the lodging of the complainant's application in May 1995. The Commission recognized that it had not adopted a formal provision dealing with the problem of plurinationals until after the rejection of the complainant's application; anyhow, it stressed that this formal provision only stated what was already the practice and that it was lawful to apply the nationality condition to plurinationals to the effect that grants could not be given for research projects in any of the countries of which the plurinational holds the nationality. As to the fairness of this rule, the Commission stated that 'with regard to the possibility of access to the programme, plurinationality gives the person an additional opportunity to belong to the eligible countries. Contrarily, it limits the choice of host countries. However, it should be stressed that this limitation due to the nationality criterion does not affect only plurinational candidates. It could also be considered as "unfair" by a candidate, possessing only one nationality, who has never lived in his country of nationality and who will nevertheless not be supported to receive training in this country.`
The decision
The Ombudsman stated that principles of good administrative conduct demand that requests for information shall be replied to without undue delay. Anyhow, in the concrete case it had not been established that the Commission received the request as the complainant, according to her own statement, was no longer in possession of the postal receipt.
As to the allegation that the Commission's interpretation of the nationality condition as regards plurinationals was unlawful, the Ombudsman considered it established that at the moment the complainant's application was rejected, there was no written rule concerning the situation of plurinationals. However, the Ombudsman found that this did not imply that the Commission had to accept that plurinationals qualified under the nationality condition in the case where they held both the nationality of the research country and another nationality. The Commission had to take a stand on the question of plurinationals and the Ombudsman did not find that the stand taken infringed principles of law.