, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

1.4. There is no legal basis for considering that the Article 93(1) procedure cannot be used in cases where the Commission has previously approved aid under Article 92(3).

1.5. The letter in question did not purport to be binding on the Member State, nor did it purport to alter the Commission's 1990 decision concerning the Stromeinspeisegesetz. The letter did not therefore appear to contain any element which exceeded the competence of the Commission under Article 93(1).

1.6. The Ombudsman's inquiry into the complainants' first claim did, therefore, reveal no maladministration.

2.

The complainants' second claim

2.1. The complainants' second claim was, in substance, that the Commission had wrongly assessed the legal and economic situation of wind energy producers because it relied on unverified data supplied by the German electricity industry.

2.2. Article 93(1) does not lay down specific requirements concerning the Commission's cooperation with Member States to keep under review existing systems of aid. However, as a matter of good administrative practice, the Commission should base its technical and economic assessments on accurate information and ensure, when appropriate, that there is opportunity for critical appraisal of relevant data and that different opinions are heard.

2.3. In its opinion the Commission had provided an account of its activities which was not contradicted by the complainants. According to the Commission, it had informed the German Government about complaints it had received concerning the system of aid for wind energy and had asked for its comments. After a hearing in the German Parliament to discuss whether or not amendments to the law were necessary, the Commission had received the comments of all participants, among them representatives of the governments of the German Länder, of energy supply companies and of associations in favour of renewable energies. In addition to this, several meetings with all concerned parties, including representatives of wind energy producers, had taken place.

2.4. On the basis of the above, it appeared that the Commission had taken reasonable steps to ensure that its technical and economic assessments were based on accurate information and that there was opportunity for critical appraisal of relevant data and that different opinions were heard. The Ombudsman's inquiry into the complainants' second claim did, therefore, reveal no maladministration.