, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

... The Commission is aware that in individual cases there may be difficulties with purchasing a car in Finland or Denmark, the possible reasons for which have already been explained to you in writing by the relevant department. The fairly comprehensive exchange of correspondence to date arising from your case shows that the Commission has taken action within the sphere of its responsibilities. In view of the understandable desire of millions of drivers in the European Union to buy their cars as cheaply as possible, and also in view of the difficulties that sometimes occur when they do so, the Commission cannot take action in each individual case involving a personal interest ...".

The complainant considered the Commission's reference to cases of personal interest inappropriate, as he pursued this matter in the interest of the general public.

Against this background, Mr R. put forward six grievances in his complaint:

(i)

the Commission was inactive in pending procedures;

(ii)

the Commission tolerated illegal practices and continuous and systematic violation of Regulation (EC) No 1475/95;

(iii)

the Commission failed to monitor the applicable rules;

(iv)

the Commission did not take seriously proven violations of the law;

(v)

the Commission wrongly assessed whether procedures should be initiated against the car manufacturers who allegedly violate the relevant competition rules;

(vi)

the Commission ignored the citizen's right to complain.

In brief, the complaint was to the effect that the Commission had been passive in the matter complained of or that the course of action taken by the Commission had been inappropriate.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission explained that the overall issue concerns alleged obstacles to parallel exports of new motor vehicles from certain Member States. It is implied in Commission Regulation (EC) No 1475/95 that a dealer may not reject a consumer's offer to buy, or ask for a higher price, simply because the consumer is a resident of another Member State.