, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

1.4. On this basis, it must be concluded that the question of proper communication of information to MEPs is a question that lies within the Parliament's powers of internal organisation. In exercising these powers, the Parliament shall, according to the case-law of the Community Courts, act in conformity with the interests of good administration(14). The question is thus whether Parliament acted accordingly.

It appeared that in this case, Parliament sent out a communication to the Members concerning the time limit introduced in the pension scheme through the internal distribution system of Parliament. As a supplementary way of ensuring the communication to MEPs, the Parliament also sent it by ordinary mail to each MEP's home address. Thus, the individual Member had at least two occasions to get knowledge of the time limit introduced. This did not appear to constitute an instance of maladministration.

2.

Unfair and discriminatory treatment

2.1. As for the question whether the refusal to admit the complainants to the scheme with retroactive effect was unfair and discriminatory, it appeared that this question covered two issues. The first issue is whether it was unfair that the Regulation in general did not provide for joining with retroactive effect. The second issue is whether the time limit for joining the pension scheme in the complainants' case should have been waived. In this context, it seemed to be common ground between the complainants and Parliament that waiving the time limit in their case would entail joining with retroactive effect. Thus, it was clear that if the first question was answered to the effect that there should be a general possibility for joining with retroactive effect, the second question was made redundant.

2.2. As concerned the first question, it was common ground between the complainants and Parliament that the Regulation did not contain any provision to the effect that the scheme could be joined retroactively. The question was thus whether it was fair that Parliament had not introduced such a provision. It appeared that Parliament had not done so for reasons of sound financial management of the scheme. Furthermore, it shall be noticed that it was within Parliament's powers not to set up a scheme at all. Thus, the Parliament must also be entitled to lay down limitations on the scheme for the said reasons.

  • celex=31974D0097