In four of the files opened by the Commission pursuant to Mr R.'s complaints, the investigations initiated led the Commission to the provisional conclusion that his complaints did not represent sufficient Community interest, and it informed him correspondingly in the so-called Article 6 letter of 16 December 1997. As stated above, it follows from the case-law of the Court that such a letter puts an end to a possible failure to act on a complaint. It remained still to be seen which final conclusion the Commission was going to reach in due course, after having studied the complainant's extensive observations. Under these circumstances, it would not have been appropriate for the Ombudsman to enter into an assessment of the merits of the letter. However, the letter led the Ombudsman to formulate below further remarks to the attention of the Commission.
Thus, as things stood, the Ombudsman found that it was not justified to claim that the Commission had been passive or taken an inappropriate course of action. Although Mr R. may have wanted the Commission to deploy more resources to this matter, which was of high concern to him, there appeared to be no grounds for the claim that the Commission had been inactive or taken an inappropriate course of action.
On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the European Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
Further remarks
The European Ombudsman was created among others to enhance relations between the European institutions and the European citizens. This task implies that the Ombudsman should also help secure the position of citizens by promoting good administrative practices and encourage administrative authorities to seek solutions that will improve their relations with citizens. Against that background, the European Ombudsman shall make the following suggestions:
Without prejudice to the non-binding nature of the so-called Article 6 letter, the Commission could on its own initiative seek to give comprehensive and adequate reasons for its intention to close the file on a complaint in the letter, thus enabling the citizen to fully comprehend the position of the Commission and to lodge adequate observations. This would appear to be in accordance with principles of good administration.